1.Policy Statement
1.1 West Midlands Fire Service and West Midlands Fire and Rescue Authority are committed to consulting effectively with our communities and stakeholders on key issues and meeting our various statutory duties to consult.
1.2 We will ensure consultation is informative, collaborative, accessible, timely and transparent. Formal consultation processes will only form a part of a wider and continuous process of engagement with our communities.
1.3 West Midlands Fire Service and West Midlands Fire and Rescue Authority aim to actively listen and welcome feedback not only through consultation but also via our Compliments and Complaints policy to keep people engaged, informed and reassured in relation to changes in our service delivery, or the performance of our duties.
2. Scope
2.1 This policy applies only to public and externally facing consultation, be that to communities or stakeholders, although our staff and representative bodies are also welcome to contribute to such consultation exercises.
2.2 Internal consultation with representative bodies and WMFS staff (including volunteers) is determined by our Employee Relations Framework and other relevant People Policies.
2.3 All uses of the terms “consult” and “consultation” in this document should be assumed to refer only to external consultation except where otherwise indicated.
3. Purpose
3.1 The purpose of this policy is to set out when, how and who West Midlands Fire Service and West Midlands Fire and Rescue Authority will consult with when undertaking any consultation process.
3.2 With this policy we aim to:
- Provide a definition of consultation and the principles of good consultation.
- Clarify when a strategic or operational decision requires consultation.
- Ensure we meet our statutory duties to consult and comply with relevant guidance.
- Ensure a consistent and inclusive approach to consultation.
- Inform our communities when they can expect to be consulted and how they will be able to provide their views.
4. Responsibility
4.1 Staff are expected to:
- Consider whether any projects or change processes they are involved in might require or benefit from public consultation in line with the definitions and principles set out in this policy.
- Seek out the assistance of the Strategy and Communications teams in determining whether consultation is required and if so, in what form.
- Support the delivery of effective consultation on any area for which they have responsibility, and those consultations of service-wide importance.
4.2 The Fire and Rescue Authority are expected to:
- Ensure it meets all legal duties to consult.
- Seek advice from officers and external partners as required to determine when consultation is required or appropriate.
- Actively promote consultations as an important part of the decision-making process, even where it is not required by law.
4.3 The Strategy Department and Communications Department are expected to:
- Ensure any consultation is undertaken effectively and in line with relevant principles.
- Actively promote external consultation within the service.
- Support other staff members to undertake consultation where necessary.
- Seek to engage communities and stakeholders outside of formal consultation processes.
5. What do we mean by consultation?
5.1 The Consultation Institute defines consultation as “The dynamic process of dialogue between individuals or groups, based upon a genuine exchange of views and, with the objective of influencing decisions, policies or programmes of action.”
5.2 This makes clear that consultation is not limited to large-scale, formal consultation exercises, but to any time the organisation seeks two-way communication with communities and partners in a way which may influence what we do.
5.3 It is important that the service and authority seek to consult in this widest possible sense. However, this policy will focus particularly on formal consultation processes.
6. What does effective consultation look like?
6.1 The Cabinet Office has set out 11 principles for government departments when considering formal consultation exercises. Although these do not apply directly across to a local authority context, they can be broadly translated as ensuring that consultation;
- Is clear and concise – using plain English.
- Is purposeful and meaningful – consultation is not undertaken to tick a box or just meet a duty but can have a real impact and must be at such a point as to be able to influence decision making.
- Is informative – enough information is provided to those being consulted to allow them to contribute meaningfully.
- Forms only a part of a wider process of ongoing engagement.
- Is proportionate in length and who it targets – there should be enough time to contribute and those consulted should be impacted by the change being proposed.
- Is accessible to those that are being consulted – the needs of those being consulted should be considered.
- Can be scrutinised – the results of the consultation are published including at least a summary of the responses received.
- Is responded to in a timely way – once feedback is received, those consulting should provide a clear and timely response which sets out how the consultation has influenced decision making.
6.2 The Gunning Principles set out a smaller list of four principles which if followed should ensure that consultation is lawful, and therefore less likely to be subject to legal challenge.
7. Duties to consult
7.1 West Midlands Fire and Rescue Authority and West Midlands Fire Service are subject to several statutory duties to consult.
7.2 Best Value Duty
As a Best Value Authority under the Local Government Act 1999, Fire Authorities “must make arrangements to secure continuous improvement in the way in which its functions are exercised, having regard to a combination of economy, efficiency and effectiveness.” In turn, “for the purpose of deciding how to fulfil the duty an authority must consult representatives of persons liable to pay any tax, precept or levy to or in respect of the authority, representatives of persons liable to pay non-domestic rates in respect of any area within which the authority carries out functions, representatives of persons who use or are likely to use services provided by the authority, and representatives of persons appearing to the authority to have an interest in any area within which the authority carries out functions.” Subsequent guidance from Government makes clear that this consultation should be “inclusive, open and fair”, and stipulates that such consultation should include specific stakeholders such as community organisations and small businesses. It does not dictate when or how often such consultation must occur.
7.3 Fire Service National Framework
Under the Fire and Rescue Service Framework (which is statutory guidance to which Authority must have regard), Fire Authorities are required to, while developing their Community Risk Management Plan (CRMP), “reflect effective consultation throughout its development and at all review stages with the community, its workforce and representative bodies and partners”. CRMP must cover a period of at least three years.
7.4 Fire and Rescue Services Act
There are specific requirements under section 18A of the Act for fire and rescue authorities to consult any persons they deem appropriate before charging for any action or service.
7.5 Equality Act 2010
The Equality Act 2010 states that public bodies such as the Fire and Rescue Authority must have “due regard” to a variety of Equalities objectives. To ensure the Authority are delivering this; we must undertake Equality Impact Analysis to demonstrate that decision-makers are fully aware of the impact that changes may have on stakeholders (see Service’s Equality Impact Assessment process for more). Such a process may involve formal consultation with potentially impacted parties.
7.6 Doctrine of legitimate expectation
Beyond specific requirements to consult, the doctrine of legitimate expectation, an accepted part of common law, means citizens may be able to challenge a lack of consultation where they have a legitimate expectation that it will take place, even if there is no specific duty to consult. This includes situations where consultation has been promised (even where it is not statutorily required), where there is a withdrawal of a benefit or service which would have a significant impact or where guidance or policies indicate we should behave a particular way. In addition, when consultation does take place, even when not statutorily required, it must be undertaken fairly and properly, or there is also a risk of judicial review.
8. When we will consult
8.1 The service and authority will consult whenever it is statutorily required to do so. This includes;
- When developing the Community Risk Management Plan (which also allows us to meet our Best Value Duty).
- When proposing to charge for services.
- Whenever we have given an undertaking to do so.
8.2 In addition, the service and authority will consult whenever it is proposed to make significant changes to service delivery that will impact on any part of our community. This could include, but is not limited to;
- Permanent closure or relocation of any of our fire stations.
- Permanent withdrawal or addition of frontline firefighting appliances (vehicles) available on our fire stations or a change which represents a substantial modification to the capability of those vehicles.
- Permanent changes to how our stations are crewed that would lead to a change in the number of firefighters riding frontline fire appliances.
- Complete withdrawal of a significant and regularly provided direct service to the public. Consultation may also be considered where a new service is to be introduced.
8.3 In determining whether a change is “significant” the Service and Authority will seek appropriate legal advice, to ensure consultation is undertaken when necessary.
8.4 The Authority will also provide the opportunity for relevant stakeholders to provide feedback on its budget as part of the annual budget setting process. This consultation may be necessarily restricted in length because of the tight timeline for budget setting dictated by national government.
9. Who we will consult
9.1 Consultation will be targeted towards those who may be impacted by a decision. For example, in relation to changes to a particular fire station, residents and those working in the area directly served by that station would be the focus of consultation, with consultation activity and events taking place in that local area. Consultation may need to be undertaken in several different geographical areas simultaneously, rather than automatically taking place at a West Midlands wide level, to ensure that a targeted approach is maintained.
9.2 The authority and service will actively consider demographic and protected groups which may be particularly impacted, utilising the existing Equality Impact Assessment process to identify such groups and determine the most appropriate consultation approach.
9.3 Where possible, the authority and service will seek to engage with organisations or bodies that, in our view, represent groups that we are seeking to consult. However, such consultation will not be a replacement for direct engagement with impacted groups.
9.4 No targeting will preclude other individuals from providing input to our consultation processes. However, the service and authority will aim to prioritise feedback from people who live, work and study within the West Midlands.
10. How we will consult
10.1 Consultation will be proportionate in scale, depth and geographical reach to the issue being consulted upon, and the significance of the change being proposed.
10.2 The service and authority will seek to use multiple methods to consult to ensure the greatest number of individuals and organisations can engage with the process. This will include specific steps designed to ensure “hard to reach” communities who may not have easy access to the internet or other barriers to participation. This could include but is not limited to;
- Online surveys shared via social media and mailing lists
- Surveys on our website
- Postal surveys
- In person engagement events at service premises
- Attendance at external meetings, conferences etc. as appropriate.
10.3 We will seek to ensure that consultation questions are open and neutrally worded, and our communities and stakeholders are provided with the opportunity to provide considered and detailed responses as necessary. This will include the ability to submit additional evidence or supporting information.
10.4 We will always be clear on what matters are within scope of a consultation and which are not. We will ensure we never consult on matters which are already determined or where change is not possible
10.5 Where the service is targeting a specific group of individuals or stakeholders we will tailor the consultation methods to those target audiences. This will include consideration of providing consultation materials in other languages and formats (e.g. braille, larger print). Any consultation process will align with the requirements of our Accessibility Statement and relevant accessibility requirements.
10.6 All consultations will be undertaken for an appropriate period, relative to the scale and complexity of the matter being consulted upon.
10.7 We will provide a public summary of anonymised consultation responses on our website within twelve weeks of the end of any consultation process. In the case of annual budget stakeholder consultation, any feedback will be reported to the Authority as part of the formal budget setting process.
10.8 Consultation responses will then inform any final decision-making process, as part of a wide range of considerations. It should be noted that consultation is not a referendum, and there is no requirement to accept the preference of a majority of respondents. However, officers and members will ensure there is a clear link between consultation and the decision-making process, including providing consultation outcomes as part of any public decision-making report.
10.9 Any consultation will be conducted with reference to the service’s Employee Conduct in the Political Environment Policy and the requirement to maintain political neutrality.
10.10 All consultation will also be undertaken in accordance with the Cabinet Office Consultation Principles (Appendix A) and the Gunning Principles (Appendix B).
Appendix A – Cabinet Office Consultation Principles
The government has published a revised set of government consultation principles. These principles give clear guidance to government departments on conducting consultations.
1. Consultations should be clear and concise
Use plain English and avoid acronyms. Be clear what questions you are asking and limit the number of questions to those that are necessary. Make them easy to understand and easy to answer. Avoid lengthy documents when possible and consider merging those on related topics.
2. Consultations should have a purpose
Do not consult for the sake of it. Ask departmental lawyers whether you have a legal duty to consult. Take consultation responses into account when taking policy forward. Consult about policies or implementation plans when the development of the policies or plans is at a formative stage. Do not ask questions about issues on which you already have a final view.
3. Consultations should be informative
Give enough information to ensure that those consulted understand the issues and can give informed responses. Include validated impact assessments of the costs and benefits of the options being considered when possible; this might be required where proposals have an impact on business or the voluntary sector.
4. Consultations are only part of a process of engagement
Consider whether informal iterative consultation is appropriate, using new digital tools and open, collaborative approaches. Consultation is not just about formal documents and responses. It is an on-going process.
5. Consultations should last for a proportionate amount of time
Judge the length of the consultation on the basis of legal advice and taking into account the nature and impact of the proposal. Consulting for too long will unnecessarily delay policy development. Consulting too quickly will not give enough time for consideration and will reduce the quality of responses.
6. Consultations should be targeted
Consider the full range of people, business and voluntary bodies affected by the policy, and whether representative groups exist. Consider targeting specific groups if appropriate. Ensure they are aware of the consultation and can access it. Consider how to tailor consultation to the needs and preferences of particular groups, such as older people, younger people or people with disabilities that may not respond to traditional consultation methods.
7. Consultations should take account of the groups being consulted
Consult stakeholders in a way that suits them. Charities may need more time to respond than businesses, for example. When the consultation spans all or part of a holiday period, consider how this may affect consultation and take appropriate mitigating action, such as prior discussion with key interested parties or extension of the consultation deadline beyond the holiday period.
8. Consultations should be agreed before publication
Seek collective agreement before publishing a written consultation, particularly when consulting on new policy proposals. Consultations should be published on gov.uk.
9. Consultation should facilitate scrutiny
Publish any response on the same page on gov.uk as the original consultation, and ensure it is clear when the government has responded to the consultation. Explain the responses that have been received from consultees and how these have informed the policy. State how many responses have been received.
10. Government responses to consultations should be published in a timely fashion
Publish responses within 12 weeks of the consultation or provide an explanation why this is not possible. Where consultation concerns a statutory instrument publish responses before or at the same time as the instrument is laid, except in very exceptional circumstances (and even then, publish responses as soon as possible). Allow appropriate time between closing the consultation and implementing policy or legislation.
11. Consultation exercises should not generally be launched during local or national election periods
If exceptional circumstances make a consultation absolutely essential (for example, for safeguarding public health), departments should seek advice from the Propriety and Ethics team in the Cabinet Office. This document does not have legal force and is subject to statutory and other legal requirements.
Appendix B – The Gunning Principles
The Gunning Principles are a set of rules for public consultation that were proposed in 1985 by Stephen Sedley QC in the case of R v London Borough of Brent ex parte Gunning.
They are four rules, which if followed, should ensure consultation is fair and lawful;
- that consultation must be at a time when proposals are still at a formative stage;
- that the consultor must give sufficient reasons for any proposal to permit of intelligent consideration and response;
- that adequate time is given for consideration and response; and
- that the product of consultation is conscientiously taken into account when finalising the decision.