Bullying, Harassment & Sexual Harm
Where applicable, we publish responses to requests under the Freedom of Information Act 2000. This one, Bullying, Harassment & Sexual Harm, is detailed below.
Other FOI's
Ref: FOI25120
RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT 2000 REQUEST
I am writing to confirm that the West Midlands Fire Service has now completed its search for the information you requested on 08/08/2025.
Please find below a summary of our findings:
Request:
What data does your organisation collect about incidents or concerns related to workplace bullying, harassment or sexual harm?
– For clarity, this includes requests for advice, assistance, informal notifications or formal complaints relating to these types of behaviour.
Reply:
Data collection is for formal complaints relating to these types of behaviour. Data collected in relation to the respondent covers:
- Type of behaviour
- Gender
- Age
- Race
- Religion
- Sexual orientation
- Outcome of case
- Outcome of appeals (if any made)
Request:
Please provide a list or schema of all data fields used to record or track information about workplace bullying, harassment or sexual harm, at any stage of the process your organisation follows (from initial contact to case closure).
– Please include an explanation of the classifications used in each data field and any specific terminology, so it can be easily understood by someone from outside your organisation.
Reply:
- Case title
- Name of respondent
- Case status
- Date opened
- Names of Investigating Officers
- Name of Service Liaison Officer
- Name of HR support
- Date Terms of Reference are sent
- Date investigation completed
- Investigation duration
- Hearing date
- Duration to hearing
- Hearing date
- Outcome
- Appeal hearing date
- Appeal outcome
- Total duration
- Log of any delays during process
- Comments
- Debrief forms sent
- Was a structured debrief held?
- Recommendations from debrief
- Date of action of recommendation
Request:
Please provide a list of all reports produced by your organisation that relate to workplace bullying, harassment or sexual harm?
– Please include a brief explanation for each report of:
- who is responsible for its creation (i.e. the job title/role, not individual names)
- how often they are produced
- the purpose of the report, and
- the information and any data fields contained in each report.
- to whom they are distributed (job titles/roles)
- whether the reports are shared externally (e.g. with elected members, Local Authority governance bodies, HMICFRS or other regulators, unions and associations, the general public)
Reply:
Investigation Report:
This report is created by the Investigation Manager who is usually of Station Commander rank or the Support Staff manager equivalent.
Reports are produced for every case that is investigated under the formal disciplinary procedure including cases of workplace bullying, harassment or sexual harm.
The report is written based on the established facts. It will also include any witnesses that has been interviewed, any associated paperwork/evidence and the investigating managers recommendation on whether there is a case for hearing, a case for informal action or a no case to answer.
The report is shared with the Senior HR Manager and the Head of People for a decision on whether the case is to go to a disciplinary hearing. If the case goes to hearing the report is shared with the respondent, their representative, the hearing manager and the HR Specialist supporting the hearing.
Scrutiny Report:
This report is created by the Senior HR Manager, which is produced quarterly.
The purpose of the report is to give an overview of all Grievance, Disciplinary and Employment Tribunal cases to the Senior Leadership Team and the Authority Members.
Although not exclusive to, it includes all cases of workplace bullying, harassment and sexual harm.
Request:
Please provide responses to Q4-7 for the period 2020-2025 (inclusive), broken down by calendar year and listed under the headings of
(a) workplace bullying
(b) harassment
(c) sexual harm
The total number of incidents recorded.
Please also break these down according to any sub-categorisations you use internally to differentiate types of bullying, harassment or sexual harm incidents.
Reply:
Please refer to table below.
Request:
The number of incidents that involved a formal investigation, broken down to show:
- internal investigations (i.e. those conducted by people employed by your organisation)
- ii. independent external investigations (i.e. external lawyers, investigators or other 3rd parties engaged for the purpose of conducting the investigation)
- The outcomes of the investigations completed in Q5 (using whatever categorisations your organisation records internally against cases).
Reply:
Answers to the above are set out in the table below.
Key: G = Grievance, D = Disciplinary
| 2020 | |||||
| Case | Informal | Formal | Internal or External | Outcome | |
| Bullying | G14-20: Allegations of bullying and making snide comments | Formal | Internal | Not upheld | |
| G12-20: Allegations of bullying for raising a complaint | Formal | Internal | Upheld | ||
| G15-20: Allegations of bullying from Line Manager | Formal | Internal | Not upheld | ||
| Harassment | D6-20: Allegation of harassment against 5 personnel in the same watch | Formal | Internal | Dismissal | |
| Sexual | N/A | ||||
| 2021 | |||||
| Case | Informal | Formal | Internal or External | Outcome | |
| Bullying | N/A | ||||
| Harassment | D3-21 : Contacting ex-partner (also Firefighter) when told not to make contact. | Yes | Internal | Final Written Warning | |
| Sexual | D15/21 – Sexual assault on FF | Yes | Internal | Final Written warning | |
| 2022 | |||||
| Case | Informal | Formal | Internal or External | Outcome | |
| Bullying | G10-22: Employee claimed that they were subjected to bullying by colleagues from other station | Yes | Internal | Employee refused to share names or information so team unable to investigate, which was accepted by employee. | |
| G16-22: Employee alleged they had experienced bullying due to their medical condition | Yes | Internal | No evidence to support the allegation, grievance not upheld | ||
| G21-22: Employee alleged that following their disciplinary, they have been subject to bullying by another employee | Yes | Internal | Grievance e upheld – management investigation commenced. | ||
| D5-22 bullying behaviour by Trainee FF | Yes | Internal | Final written warning | ||
| D13-22: Allegation that Officer placed items of clothing into station freezer | Yes | Internal | Final written warning | ||
| D20-23: Allegation of employee bullying another colleague | Yes | Internal | |||
| Harassment | N/A | ||||
| Sexual | D8-22: Trainee FF allegedly demonstrated inappropriate behaviours deemed as sexual. | Yes | Internal | Final Written Warning | |
| D12-22: Employee arrested and charged for Serious sex offences | Yes | Internal | Dismissal | ||
| 2023 | |||||
| Case | Informal | Formal | Internal or External | Outcome | |
| Bullying | G1-23 : Employee alleged bullying and intimidation by Manager who they stated spat in their mouth | Yes | Internal | No evidence,, grievance and appeal not upheld | |
| Harassment | D9-23: Employee alleged to have made remarks of a racial and discriminatory nature | Yes | Internal | Dismissal | |
| Sexual | D1-23: Manager accused of making sexual advances when attending an external event | Yes | Internal | Dismissal | |
| D4-23: Allegations that an Officer made contact with a Trainee FF through social media compromising their position | Yes | Internal | Reduction in rank and final written warning | ||
| D8-23: Employee arrested for sexual offence | yes | Internal | Allegations dropped as claimant no longer wanted to pursue and Police stopped investigation. Case dropped | ||
| 2024 | |||||
| Case | Informal | Formal | Internal or External | Outcome | |
| Bullying | G10-24: Employee alleged experiencing intimidation from colleague whilst attending incident. | Yes | Internal | Partially upheld. Development plans issued to colleague. | |
| G15-24: Employee alleged two colleagues talking ill of them resulting in them being ostracised by colleagues. They felt bullied and isolated | Yes | Internal | |||
| Harassment | G6-24: employee is aggrieved that other employee who they were in a relationship with previously is now bullying the individual. | Yes | Internal | Not upheld. | |
| Sexual | N/A | ||||
| 2025 | |||||
| Case | Informal | Formal | Internal or External | Outcome | |
| Bullying | N/A | ||||
| Harassment | N/A | ||||
| Sexual | D16-25: Allegations of exhibiting behaviour towards trainee FF that could be Bullying and sexual harassment | Yes | Internal | Currently under investigation | |
Request:
The number of people who have left your organisation who were:
- complainants (i.e. people who raised any inquiry or complaint)
- respondents (i.e. people who were the subject of any inquiry or complaint allegations)
Reply:
| Year | Complainant | Respondent |
| 2020 | 2 | 6 |
| 2021 | 0 | 5 |
| 2022 | 0 | 3 |
| 2023 | 3 | 17 |
| 2024 | 5 | 8 |
| 2025 | 1 | 8 |
Request:
Please provide responses to Q8-9 for the period 2020-2025 (inclusive), broken down by calendar year:
The number of settlement agreements (or other legal agreements containing any form of non-disclosure requirement) signed by people leaving your organisation who were:
- complainants who raised any inquiry or complaint about workplace bullying, harassment or sexual harm.
- respondents who were the subject of any inquiry or complaint about workplace bullying, harassment or sexual harm.
Reply:
| Year | Complainants | Respondents |
| 2020 | 0 | 0 |
| 2021 | 0 | 0 |
| 2022 | 0 | 0 |
| 2023 | 0 | 0 |
| 2024 | 2 | 0 |
| 2025 | 0 | 0 |
Request:
The amount spent by your organisation on external legal advice for:
- legal services or advice provided in conducting independent investigations in Q5 (ii)
- other advice provided about any other matters involving workplace bullying, harassment or sexual harm
Reply:
All costs relating to any legal services, advice, employment tribunals and investigations are collated within these 2 areas.
2020/2021
External Services Legal – £39,620
Legal Services (including Sandwell Council SLA) – £16,150
2021/2022
External Services Legal – £99,570
Legal Services (including Sandwell Council SLA) – £76,660
2022/2023
External Services Legal – £64,680
Legal Services (including Sandwell Council SLA) – £147,640
2023/2024
External Services Legal – £26,100
Legal Services (including Sandwell Council SLA) – £89,370
2024/25
External Services Legal – £36,470
Legal Services (including Sandwell Council SLA) – £690,810
If you have any queries about this Freedom of Information request, please contact us. Please remember to quote the reference number above in any future communications.
For service complaints, issues or comments regarding this request, please contact:
The Public Relations Department, West Midlands Fire Service, 99 Vauxhall Road, Birmingham, B7 4HW.
Further information concerning Freedom of Information requests can be found on the Information Commissioner website at either the following link: https://ico.org.uk/ or at Wycliffe House, Water Lane, Wilmslow, SK9 5AF.