Policy Statement
1.1 This policy strives towards a workplace and place of learning based on equity for all, not just equality. Equality is giving each person or group of people the same resources and opportunities. Equity is about distributing those resources based on individual needs. Put simply, Equality is giving everyone the same pair of shoes. Equity is giving everyone a pair of shoes that fit.
1.2 We recognise that our people are the cornerstone of West Midlands Fire Service (WMFS) and the driving force behind the incredible work we do. We have a duty of care to create and foster a safe learning and working environment where our people feel safe and supported, whatever their circumstances. This policy reflects our commitment to promote a positive, diverse, and inclusive culture and environment in which people are treated fairly and with respect in line with our Promises.
1.3 This policy is the main point of reference for how we will manage any form of bullying, harassment, victimisation, violence, and discrimination. We encourage all of our learners and employees to play an active role in creating and maintaining an environment in which bullying, harassment and discrimination are understood to be unacceptable forms of behaviour and ensure that managers are supported and equipped to properly manage matters relating to Diversity, Inclusion and Dignity at Work.
Scope
2.1 This policy applies to anyone working for us. This includes job applicants, apprentices, employees, contractors, external agencies involved in apprenticeship training/assessment and volunteers. The policy is relevant to all stages of the employment relationship to ensure equity and diversity principles are embedded throughout the Service. The policy also applies to bullying, or harassment, by third parties.
2.2 This policy applies covers all areas of apprenticeship training and delivery.
2.3 WMFS will not tolerate any form of bullying, harassment, sexual harassment, violence and victimisation, unlawful and unfair discrimination, in accordance with the Equality Act 2010, specifically in relation to the nine protected characteristics:
- Age
- Disability
- Gender Reassignment
- Marriage and Civil Partnership
- Pregnancy and Maternity
- Race
- Religion or Belief
- Sex
- Sexual Orientation
2.4 At WMFS we are committed to going beyond these and will therefore include further characteristics of class/socio-economic background, gender identity, issues relating to health, employment status, physical characteristics and criminal records.
2.5 Any behaviour, act or conduct which is found to be a breach of the Equity, Diversity and Dignity at Work policy will be investigated and dealt with under the Disciplinary policy.
2.6 Sexual Harassment, prevention of sexual harassment in the workplace, and how to report this is covered in the Sexual Harassment Policy.
2.7 You should be aware that you can be personally liable for harassment.
What does Equity, Diversity and Dignity at Work mean to WMFS?
3.1 We celebrate workplace diversity and are proud of our differences. We want people to look forward to their working day. Nobody should ever be belittled, bullied, harassed, made to feel different or unwelcome.
3.2 We aim to be open, honest, mutually respectful, kind, rigorous and courteous in all that we do. We will strive to work with all employees in a collaborative, constructive and respectful manner to achieve this.
3.3 We expect all individuals to act in a way that represents our Values and to behave in a reasonable way towards each other. Likewise, we expect our managers to support our employees and learners in a way that enables them to grow and feel safe at work.
3.4 We place a high level of trust in our people. The Community we support are entitled to have absolute confidence in our Service and our employees are expected to act and behave in a way that does not call this trust into question.
3.5 This policy cannot cover every situation. To help you think about any situation where you are unsure whether your behaviour or actions could breach this policy, work through the questions in the Integrity Checklist. If you are unable to tick against each point, then please seek advice or support from your line manager, or your union representative.
Integrity Checklist:
- Are my actions or behaviours in keeping with WMFS Values?
- Is what I’m doing (or considering) ethical, and in line with the Dignity at Work policy and other people policies?
- Is it legal and am I authorised to behave in this way?
- Have I thoroughly understood the potential risks, including risks to mine and WMFS’s reputation?
- Am I leading by example?
- If my actions/behaviours become public knowledge, will I still feel like I have done the right thing?
- Have I fully considered the feelings of those around me?
Our Commitment to the Principles of the Modern Slavery Act 2015
4.1 West Midlands Fire Service is committed to the principles of the Modern Slavery Act 2015 and the abolition of modern slavery and human trafficking.
4.2 Modern Slavery is used as umbrella terms to refer to the illegal exploitation of people for personal or commercial gain. It covers a wide range of abuse and exploitation including, slavery, human trafficking, servitude, and forced or compulsory labour. Victims of Modern Slavery can be of any age, gender, nationality, and ethnicity. They are tricked or threatened into work and may feel unable to leave or report the crime through fear or intimidation. They also may not recognise themselves as a victim. Victims may also be subject to more than one type of exploitation at the same time.
4.3 We are committed to eliminating discrimination and exploitation in all business dealings or our supply chain, acting with transparency, putting effective systems and controls in place to safeguard against all forms of Modern Slavery.
4.4 As an employer, we’re committed to creating and ensuring a non-discriminatory and respectful working environment for our employees. We want all our employees to feel confident that they can expose wrongdoing without any risk to themselves.
4.5 Our recruitment and people management processes are designed to ensure that all prospective employees are legally entitled to work in the UK and to safeguard employees from any abuse or coercion.
4.6 We do not enter into business with any organisation, in the UK or abroad, which knowingly supports or is found to be involved in slavery, servitude and forced or compulsory labour.
Responsibilities
5.1 Employees and apprentices
We expect all employees and apprentices to:
- Treat others with dignity and respect and be aware of how their behaviour affects those around them.
- Take personal responsibility for observing, upholding, promoting and applying this policy. Whatever your job is, this is part of your role. If you experience or witness any form of bullying or harassment, we encourage you to speak up without delay and to ask for appropriate support. Any dealings you have with third parties, including suppliers and contractors must be free from discrimination, harassment, victimisation or bullying.
- Intervene to stop bullying, harassment, sexual harassment, victimisation, bullying, violence and discrimination in the workplace.
- Attend relevant training as it becomes available.
5.2 People Managers
We expect all People Managers to:
- Lead by example and treat all with dignity and respect.
- Appropriately challenge what you feel are inappropriate comments, actions or behaviours.
- Intervene to stop bullying, harassment, sexual harassment, victimisation, bullying, violence and discrimination in the workplace.
- Report promptly to Human Resources any incidences or concerns of bullying, harassment, victimisation, violence and discrimination
- Ensure you understand the relevant policies, procedures and guidance that support Dignity at Work, as well as undertaking relevant training as required.
5.3 Human Resources (HR) and the EDI (Equality, Diversity and Inclusion) Team
HR and EDI are responsible for:
- Ensuring policies and procedures are kept up to date and are accessible for all employees.
- Providing managers with advice and guidance when handling and investigating complaints relating to bullying, harassment, sexual harassment, victimisation, violence, and discrimination.
- Maintaining best practice, ensuring that the Service is kept abreast of changes in legislation.
- Provide and source training and learning opportunities designed to promote understanding of equality and diversity for all employees.
Confidentiality
6.1 Anyone involved with an informal or formal complaint around a topic covered by this policy, including witnesses, must keep the matter strictly confidential and act with appropriate sensitivity to all parties.
6.2 If you are found to have breached confidentiality or acted without due care or sensitivity, we may take disciplinary action against you up to and including dismissal.
6.3 The consequences of breaching this policy are as follows:
6.3.1 If, following a formal investigation, we find that you have committed, authorised, or condoned an act of bullying, harassment, sexual harassment, victimisation, violence, or discrimination, we will deal with the issue as a possible case of misconduct or gross misconduct up to and including dismissal under our Disciplinary Policy.
6.3.2 Anyone who complains or takes part in good faith in a bullying or harassment investigation must not suffer any form of detrimental treatment or victimisation. If we find that you have victimised anyone in this way, we will instigate disciplinary action against you up to and including dismissal under our Disciplinary procedure.
Defining Unacceptable Behaviour
7.1 Everyone has the right to decide what behaviour is unacceptable to them. Unacceptable behaviour (including bullying, harassment and victimisation) may involve actions, words or physical gestures that could reasonably be perceived to be the cause of another person’s distress or discomfort. This may be by an individual against an individual or involve groups of people. Even if you do not intend to bully or harass someone else, this does not legitimise your behaviour as it is the impact on the recipient that is important.
7.2 Whilst these are by no means restrictive, at WMFS, we make the following definitions of unacceptable behaviour:
7.2.1 Bullying
There is no legal definition of bullying. However, we regard it as conduct that is offensive, intimidating, malicious, insulting, or an abuse or misuse of power, and usually persistent, that has the effect of undermining, humiliating or injuring the recipient.
Bullying can be physical, verbal or non-verbal conduct. It might:
- be a regular pattern of behaviour or a one-off incident
- happen face-to-face, on social media, in emails or calls
- happen at work or in other work-related situations
- not always be obvious or noticed by others
If the bullying relates to a person’s protected characteristic, it may also constitute harassment and, therefore, will be unlawful (see ‘Harassment’ below).
Examples of bullying
While this is not an exhaustive list, bullying may include:
- physical, verbal or psychological threats.
- constantly criticising someone’s work
- spreading malicious rumours about someone
- constantly putting someone down in meetings
- deliberately giving someone a heavier workload than everyone else
- purposefully excluding someone from team social events
- putting humiliating, offensive or threatening comments or photos on social media
It is important to understand that legitimate, reasonable, and constructive criticism of a person’s performance or behaviour, or reasonable instructions given to people in the course of their employment, will not of themselves amount to bullying. However, questioning someone’s every decision or belittling them by not allowing them to complete their own work with no legitimate reason could surmount to bullying.
Someone may also experience upwards bullying. This can be one employee or a group and would be directed at someone more senior. Examples of this could include:
- showing continued disrespect
- refusing to complete tasks
- spreading rumours
- constantly undermining someone’s authority
- doing things to make someone seem unskilled or unable to do their job properly.
7.2.2 Harassment
Harassment is unwanted conduct related to a protected characteristic that has the purpose or effect of:
- violating someone else’s dignity; or
- creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment for someone else.
Harassment can also occur where someone perceives another person to have a protected characteristic, for example a perception that someone is transgender even if they are not.
Harassment can also arise by association, where someone is harassed because they are associated with someone with a protected characteristic, for example having a family member of a particular religion.
Examples of harassment
Harassment can occur in many forms and can take place either at work or outside work. While this is not an exhaustive list, examples include:
- “banter”, jokes, taunts or insults that are sexist, racist, ageist, transphobic, homophobic or derogatory against any other protected characteristic.
- unwanted physical behaviour, for example, pushing or grabbing.
- excluding someone from a conversation or a social event or marginalising them from the group.
- derogatory comments about pregnancy, maternity leave or IVF treatment.
- mimicking or making fun of someone’s disability.
- derogatory or offensive comments about religion.
- unwelcome comments about someone’s appearance or the way they dress that is related to a protected characteristic.
- “outing” (i.e., revealing their sexual orientation against their wishes), or threatening to “out”, someone.
- consistently using the wrong names and pronouns following the transition of a person’s gender identity.
- displaying images that are racially or otherwise offensive.
- excluding or making derogatory comments about someone because of a perceived protected characteristic, or because they are associated with someone with a protected characteristic.
7.2.3 Third Party Harassment
Third party harassment relates to feeling intimidated or offended by someone from outside of employees of WMFS. For example, this could be a contractor, a volunteer, or a member of the community.
7.2.4 Victimisation
Victimisation is being treated unfairly because you made or supported a complaint to do with a ‘protected characteristic’, or someone thinks you did.
This does not apply to those who have maliciously made or supported an untrue complaint.
7.2.5 Violence
Violence is defined as ‘any incident in which a person is abused, threatened or assaulted in circumstances relating to their work’. This includes:
- verbal abuse – shouting, swearing or insults, sexual harassment or other unwanted advances/behaviour, and racial abuse.
- threats and intimidation.
- physical violence, for example, physical attacks including slapping, kicking, spitting or shoving.
Violence in any form may require the attention of the police. WMFS will ensure that a thorough investigation is carried out and the appropriate actions are taken in accordance with our Disciplinary Policy.
7.2.6 Gaslighting
Gaslighting at work is when a person—typically a colleague or manager—invalidates what you know to be true, forcing you to question the facts and, ultimately, yourself and your ability to do your job. This could be by denying past events, downplaying your emotions, or retelling events so that you take the blame.
7.2.7 Exclusionary behaviour
Exclusionary behaviour is the everyday verbal, nonverbal, and environmental slights, snubs, or insults, whether intentional or unintentional, which communicate hostile, derogatory, or negative messages to target persons based solely upon their marginalised group membership. This is also known as microaggressions. Some examples of these are below:
Verbal – for example making stereotyped comments, continually using words or phrases that others find offensive, or making an assumption based on someone’s background or race.
Behavioural – for example giving only personality-based feedback (“you should smile more”) to a female employee during a performance review, or assuming an older colleague is unable to use technology.
Environmental – for example not offering accessible facilities or buildings or excluding people from recruitment processes on the basis of a protected characteristic.
Micro-assaults – conscious and obvious insults made verbally or non-verbally to a marginalised individual or group, for example directing limp-wristed hand gestures towards a gay colleague and saying “it’s just a joke”.
Micro-insults – unintentionally insensitive remarks or assumptions based on stereotypes, for example saying to a person with a disability “you don’t look disabled to me”.
Micro-invalidations – where a person denies, or seeks to cancel, the feelings and lived experiences of a marginalised individual or group, for example a white person saying “I don’t think the UK has a problem with racism – some people are just too sensitive”.
Serious exclusionary behaviour can amount to unlawful harassment, bullying or discrimination, but even less serious forms of this behaviour can negatively impact the health and wellbeing of the person experiencing them.
7.2.8 Ableism
Ableism describes discrimination against disabled people in favour of non-disabled people. This discrimination can be intentional or unintentional, and it can take many forms. This could be things like giving people with disabilities a lighter workload than those without disabilities, providing help when people with disabilities don’t ask for it or need it, or speaking to people with disabilities like you would a child.
Reporting Unacceptable Behaviour
8.1 At WMFS we want everyone to feel empowered to report an issue relating to Dignity at Work that you’ve seen or heard, even if it’s not directed at you. As such, we’ve tried to make the reporting of unacceptable behaviour as accessible as possible.
8.2 If you need to talk to someone you can reach out to:
- your manager
- your tutor/workplace coach
- a senior manager
- your union representative
- Human Resources
- Fire Service Chaplains
- Mental Health Advocates
- Employee Assistance Programme (a completely free and confidential service, the details of which are in section 8) – all of whom will be able to offer advice.
8.3 The responsibility for speaking up does not lie solely with victims. We all have a collective responsibility to act when we witness any form of these behaviours in the workplace and beyond. It’s crucial that no one turns their heads away when incidents occur.
8.4 Raising a Complaint
If you wish to raise a concern or issue about Dignity at Work you can do so in the following ways:
8.4.1 Informal route
Bully or harasser is a colleague
If you feel able to, you may decide to raise the issue with the individual themselves, to make clear that their behaviour is not welcome and to ask them to stop. They may not be aware that their behaviour is offending you.
Alternatively, if you do not feel up to speaking directly to the individual, you may consider asking your manager or a trusted colleague for support.
You may or may not want them to talk to the individual on your behalf and where possible they will respect your wishes. However, if the welfare or safety of you or others is at risk or where your allegations are particularly serious, they may need to approach HR to instigate a formal investigation. In such a case they will discuss this with you first.
Bully or harasser is a third party
If you are experiencing bullying or harassment by a third party, for example a supplier, we encourage you to inform your manager without delay so that they can advise and support you. Your manager may also need to contact HR for support.
8.4.2 Formal Route
If you are not happy with the outcome of an informal process, or if you feel it is not appropriate to approach the issue informally, you may decide to raise it formally.
You can raise a grievance through the Grievance procedure. This involves putting your concerns in writing and the HR team help arrange for this to be investigated – either informally or formally.
You can also raise a concern through our online platform Speak Up. This gives you the option to remain anonymous, whilst also feeding into any investigation via an anonymous messaging service.
In certain circumstances we may decide to instigate a disciplinary investigation following your disclosure or following the outcome of a grievance. If this is the case, you will be informed of next steps by HR or your appointed Service Liaison Officer.
Record Keeping
9.1 We process personal data collected in relation to bullying or harassment complaints in accordance with our Management of Information Policy. In particular, data collected in relation to the investigation of bullying or harassment complaints is held securely and accessed by, and disclosed to, individuals only for the purposes of responding to the complaints and conducting an investigation. You should immediately report any inappropriate access or disclosure of employee data in accordance with the Data Protection Breach Process within the above policy. It may also constitute a disciplinary offence, which we will deal with under our disciplinary procedure.
9.2 We analyse data around allegations of bullying or harassment (in compliance with our data protection obligations) on an ongoing basis to assess the impact of this policy and our wider equality, diversity, and inclusion strategy.
Malicious Allegations
10.1 We take it for granted that allegations made under this policy are made in good faith, based on a genuine belief that the behaviour being complained of is unacceptable. Therefore, no one will ever suffer any form of detriment for reporting such an incident. However, any cases of malicious or frivolous allegations will be taken very seriously and may result in disciplinary action against the complainant.
Support for those affected or involved
11.1 We understand that anyone affected by, or involved with, a complaint of bullying or harassment may feel anxious or upset and we will do what we can to support you.
11.2 If you feel you cannot continue to work in close contact with the alleged bully/harasser, we will consider seriously any requested changes to your working arrangements during our investigation into the matter. We will never automatically move you if you have raised a complaint unless you request this.
11.3 Anyone who complains or takes part in good faith in a bullying or harassment investigation must not suffer any form of detrimental treatment or victimisation. If you feel you have suffered such victimisation, please inform your line manager or HR as soon as possible.
11.4 Regardless of the outcome of your complaint, we will consider carefully how best to approach any ongoing working relationship between you and the individual concerned. For example, depending on the specific circumstances, we may consider amending the job duties, location or reporting lines of either you or the other person. Alternatively, we may decide workplace mediation or counselling is appropriate.
11.5 If you are part of a formal procedure linked to this policy, you will be assigned a Service Liaison Officer to help you navigate the process and monitor your wellbeing.
11.6 If you are accused of bullying, harassment, or victimisation we understand that this is a very serious matter for you too. You may be worried that presumptions will be made about your guilt, or that your response will not be taken seriously.
We want to assure you that we will:
- carry out a fair, thorough and balanced investigation – maintaining appropriate confidentiality throughout.
- not presume the accusation is either true or false.
11.7 Useful Support Contacts:
Employee Assistance Programme (EAP) – 0800 023 9324 – Speak completely confidentially to a third party with anonymity assured. They offer telephone counselling, access to self-help books and podcasts, and are available 24/7, 365 days a year.
Fire Service Chaplains
Mental Health Advocates
Union Support – Your union representative can help support you with the process, attend formal meetings with you, and help you feel prepared – whilst also offering personal support.
FBU
Unison
Fire Officers Association
Online reporting platform – Speak Up
You can also contact the HR team and the Equity, Diversity and Inclusion team for advice and training around the issues raised.
Useful External Resources
ACAS Helpine:
The Acas helpline is for anyone who needs employment law or workplace advice, including apprentices, employers, employees and workers.
Contact them for confidential, free advice. They can talk through:
- any work-related problem or question you have
- what the law says and how it relates to you
- good practice at work
- your options, including any risks and benefits
Discrimination, Bullying and Harassment – ACAS guides for managers and employees
ACAS – Dealing with Unconscious Bias
ACAS Bullying and Harassment Free Course
You Tube – Equality and Human Rights Commission – What is harassment and victimisation
You Tube – Equality and Human Rights Commission – What is direct and indirect discrimination
Mind.org.uk – Difficult Working Relationships
Rightsofwomen.org.uk – sexual harassment at work advice
Sexual Harassment at Work Advice Line – Call 02074900152
West Midlands Police – Advice on sexual assault and sexual offences
National Bullying Helpline : 0300 3230169
NHS – Bullying at Work
Equality Impact Assessments
13.1 An Equality impact assessment (EIA) is used as a systematic way to assess all policies, procedures, activities and proposed projects for impact on employees of the West Midlands Fire Service and members of the public.
13.2 The aim of an equality impact assessment is to highlight the likely impact of the activity on protected characteristics. It will also determine and identify ways in which the policy should be changed or the impact mitigated.
13.3 Policy and project leads have a responsibility to undertake an EIA for their proposal. This applies to any new policy development, activity, service project or any policies being amended and reviewed should undergo an equality impact assessment.
Provision of Dignity Rooms
14.1 We are proud to offer dignity rooms for the use of all employees (and where requested and practical, visitors and/or guests). The use of the room is not specific to any particular faith and can also be used by employees who may wish to use the room during break periods for quiet reflection, wellbeing reasons or for expressing milk.
14.2 At sites with a dignity room available, the manager in charge should make sure that all employees are aware of the availability of the room.