Inspection, Enforcement of fire Safety in High-Rise Residential Buildings
Where applicable, we publish responses to requests under the Freedom of Information Act 2000. This one, Inspection, Enforcement of fire Safety in High-Rise Residential Buildings , is detailed below.
Other FOI's
WMFS OFFICIAL – NEW – FREEDOM OF INFORMATION REQUEST – FOI25141
Ref: FOI25141
RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT 2000 REQUEST
I am writing to confirm that the West Midlands Fire Service has now completed its search for the information you requested further to your Freedom of Information request.
Please find below a summary of our findings.
Request
Under the Freedom of Information Act 2000, I am requesting the following information:
Copies of any memoranda of understanding, partnership agreements, protocols, or strategies between West Midlands Fire Service and Birmingham City Council that relate to the management, inspection, or enforcement of fire safety in high-rise residential buildings (HRBs), from 1 January 2022 to the present.
Copies of correspondence (including emails, meeting notes, minutes, or briefings) between WMFS and Birmingham City Council since 1 January 2022 that reference:
Please provide the information electronically. If it is likely to exceed the appropriate cost limit, please advise how the request could be refined.
Reply
This information is exempt from disclosure under Section 31 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000. This exemption relates to law enforcement, specifically:
Section 31(1)(g) – the exercise by any public authority of its functions for any of the purposes specified in subsection (2), namely:
Section 31(2)(a) – ascertaining whether any person has failed to comply with the law; and
Section 31(2)(c) – ascertaining whether circumstances exist or may arise which would justify regulatory action.
Section 31 creates an exemption from the right to know if disclosing the information would, or would be likely to, prejudice one or more law enforcement activities. The exemption is applied to safeguard the integrity of enforcement processes, including fair trial and protection from prejudice.
This includes documents such as correspondence (emails, letters), minutes of meeting, audit/inspection notes, reports, and fire safety information provided by the ‘Responsible Person’ for the building. These are generally exempt from disclosure under FOIA.
For further context, please refer to the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) decision notice:
Public Interest Test:
Factors in favour of disclosure:
- Transparency and accountability: There is a strong public interest in understanding how public authorities such as West Midlands Fire Service (WMFS) manage fire safety inspections in high-rise residential buildings (HRBs), particularly in the wake of the Grenfell Tower tragedy.
- Public safety: Disclosure could reassure the public that appropriate inspections, enforcement, and inter-agency collaboration are taking place to ensure the safety of residents.
- Public confidence: Making such information available may enhance trust in the regulatory process and demonstrate that authorities are taking fire safety seriously.
Factors in favour of maintaining the exemption:
- Preserving the integrity of enforcement processes: Disclosure of correspondence, inspection-related documents could prejudice ongoing investigations or future enforcement actions by revealing regulatory approaches, investigative techniques, and/or sensitive discussions.
- Safe space for regulatory dialogue: WMFS relies on open and frank communication with Responsible Persons and other stakeholders. Disclosure could deter voluntary cooperation, leading to less effective regulation and slower enforcement. It’s important for us, as the authority responsible for enforcing fire safety laws, to work closely with the Responsible Persons during any fire safety checks or inspections we carry out. If that person is willing to cooperate, it helps our Fire Safety Officers have open conversations whether in person, by phone, or by email so they can fully understand the situation and decide if any action needs to be taken.
We believe that keeping this process confidential is more important than releasing the information, because sharing it could make people less willing to cooperate in the future, which would harm and/or delay our ability to take necessary enforcement action and provide adequate advice on Fire Safety.
- Risk of prejudicing future compliance: If Responsible Person believe that their communications or internal assessments may be disclosed, they may be less forthcoming, which could hinder our ability to assess compliance or take proportionate enforcement action and/or give fire safety advice.
- Precedent risk: Releasing such information could set a precedent that undermines the confidentiality of similar engagements across the sector.
- Releasing the information may cause unnecessary alarm and distress to the occupants of the premises and the information potentially misunderstood or interpret which may also cause unnecessary distress to occupants.
Request
Fire Risk Assessments (FRAs) or Safety Case Reports for HRBs managed by Birmingham City Council.
Reply
A ‘fire risk assessment’ must be produced by the ‘Responsible Person’ for the building; it is not produced by WMFS. It is the ‘Responsible Person’ who must maintain this and keep it up to date, and to implement any recommendations or actions within 5 Reference: IC-134106-M7T6 the assessment.
It is WMFS role to ensure that such a risk assessment has been carried out and that the ‘Responsible Person’ implements any actions arising from the assessment. it is the ‘Responsible Person’ who should hold the up to-date version and therefore this information is exempt under section 21 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 as this information is reasonably accessible to the requestor. Information concerning the management of fire safety or building safety risks in those HRBs should be provided to you by the Responsible Person for HRB’s under section 22 of The Regulatory reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005.
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2005/1541/article/22
A guide to Fire Safety responsibilities under Fire Safety (England) Regulation 2022 is available on the Gov.uk website please find link below:
Request
The management of fire safety or building safety risks in those HRBs.
Reply
The management of fire safety or building safety risks in those HRBs predominantly is with Responsible Person of the premises and therefore this information is exempt under section 21 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 as this information is reasonably accessible to the requestor. Information concerning the management of fire safety or building safety risks in those HRBs should be provided to you by the Responsible Person for the properties under section 22 of The Regulatory reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005.
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2005/1541/article/22
A guide to Fire Safety responsibilities under Fire Safety (England) Regulation 2022 is available on the Gov.uk website please find link below:
It is the ‘Responsible Person’ duty to share information and if they are not complying then you could approach the Housing Ombudsman at the following link:
https://www.housing-ombudsman.org.uk
Please find link below with further information.
Fire safety in the workplace: Who’s responsible – GOV.UK
Request
Enforcement action (or decisions not to take enforcement action) relating to Birmingham City Council’s HRBs.
Reply
Enforcement data from the Fire Service is publicly available therefore, is exempt under Section 21 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 as this information is reasonably accessible to the requestor. The information can be found National Fire Chiefs Council (NFCC) website at the following link:
Please find below guidance for using the enforcement register:
For service complaints, issues or comments regarding this request please contact
The Public Relations Department, West Midlands Fire Service, 99 Vauxhall Road, Birmingham, B7 4HW
Further information concerning FOI requests can be found on the Information Commissioner website https://ico.org.uk/ or by writing to:
Information Commissioner, Wycliffe House, Water Lane, Wilmslow, SK9 5AF.