If you are neurodivergent and this provides a barrier to you fully accessing any areas this policy or procedure please let your manager or a member of the HR team know so that they can discuss with you how they can make adjustments to help.
1.Introduction
1.1 At West Midlands Fire Service (WMFS), we aim to create a working environment in which all employees can freely raise concerns relating to their employment and seek a resolution promptly, fairly and informally wherever possible. Where informal resolution is not possible, the grievance procedure exists to provide a way to achieve formal resolution. The emphasis of this policy is on problem solving and mediation rather than confrontation.
1.2 As a Service we want to encourage a culture of psychological safety. This is the belief that you won’t be punished or humiliated for speaking up with ideas, questions, concerns, or mistakes. This policy therefore explains not only the process of raising your concerns, but how we can support you during this process.
1.3 We believe that everyone should be treated with dignity, respect and fairness. There may be occasions where you have problems or concerns. This may be about things such as your work, your working conditions, or your relationships with colleagues. This policy provides a framework and outlines how you can do this in a safe and supportive environment.
1.4 The policy has been written in accordance with the ACAS code of practice, and the National Joint Council For Local Authority Fire and Rescue Services Grey Book, complies with the requirements of The Equality Act (2010), and is in accordance with WMFS’s commitment to Equality and Diversity.
2.Scope
2.1 This policy applies to all employees directly employed by WMFS, regardless of their length of service.
2.2 Volunteers, workers employed via third party suppliers and agencies or engaged on a consultancy basis, are not covered by this policy.
2.3 This policy does not form part your contract of employment and therefore the Service reserves the right to change the policy and procedures at any time when considered necessary, following appropriate consultation.
2.4 This policy covers all matters which may become a source of grievance except:
- Complaints relating to the outcome of a policy that already includes the right of appeal, e.g. disciplinary, performance management, flexible working, redundancy.
Complaints already being dealt with under the Whistleblowing policy. - Matters relating to issues that are the subject of collective bargaining between the Fire Service and a trade union either at local or national level.
- Where the grievance is a matter that is outside the authority of the Fire Service, for example income tax, national insurance, or pension regulations.
- Expressing individual disappointment if you are not successful in gaining a role or promotion; nor to register your disagreement with managers performance concerns (unless the issue relates to a breach of policy regarding selection or appraisal procedures, or a breach of the Dignity at Work Policy).
2.5 This policy should not be used to raise a complaint on behalf of another employee.
2.6 It is important that the Grievance Procedure is used properly to help those who are experiencing genuine problems at work and therefore WMFS will not tolerate any abuse or misuse of this policy. Employees are not permitted to raise a grievance maliciously and, if there is clear evidence, which highlights that an allegation has been made falsely, then we may instigate the Disciplinary Policy. However, allegations that are inconclusive or where evidence does not support an allegation does not mean that they are automatically vexatious or malicious.
2.7 We recognise that a grievance procedure can be stressful and upsetting. Everyone involved in the process is entitled to be treated calmly and with respect. We will not tolerate abusive or insulting behaviour from anyone taking part in a grievance procedure and may treat any such behaviour as misconduct under our Disciplinary Policy.
3.Purpose
3.1 The focus of this policy is on open communication and early intervention where possible to avoid issues escalating in the workplace.
3.2 The purpose of this policy is to therefore:
- Provide a standard process and a consistent approach for managing workplace grievances in a fair and supportive manner.
- Promote a positive culture of psychological safety.
- Help resolve issues informally and as early as possible.
- Ensure that those involved understand the process and are supported in terms of their wellbeing.
- Establish the roles and responsibilities of all parties involved, including employees, managers, and Human Resources (HR).
4.Responsibilities
4.1 As an employee, we expect you to:
- Raise matters of concern informally in the first instance with your line manager, or the next level manager if you believe there is a conflict of interest.
- Act with professionalism and maintain confidentiality throughout the informal and formal processes
- Ensure that if you submit a formal grievance, it is submitted in writing clearly stating the reasons for the grievance and relevant background details, what action has been taken to date and what solution or outcome you are seeking.
- Co-operate with all elements of the process, including investigations and attending hearings.
- Ensure that a trade union representative or work colleague is able to attend formal hearings with you (if you wish).
- If you have difficulty at any stage of the grievance process because of a disability, language or other barriers, make this known to the grievance manager or HR as soon as possible so that adjustments can be considered.
4.2 As a manager, we expect you to comply with all of the above, and:
- Encourage staff to raise any matters with you in order to identify the cause of concern and resolve them on an informal basis where possible.
- Ensure that all concerns are dealt with in a timely and confidential manner.
- Ensure that any case that you handle is dealt with in a timely and confidential manner and that outcomes are decided without regard for any stereotypical factors or preconceptions which could lead to an unfair outcome.
- Consult with your HR Specialist about any informal or formal process being undertaken.
4.3 Human Resources (HR) are expected to:
- Provide accurate and consistent advice on cases and support the procedure to be followed.
- Identify a Grievance Manager appropriate for the task in hand (i.e. one with the necessary knowledge, skills, and impartiality).
- Attend formal meetings where it is considered appropriate.
- Ensure that appropriate training is available to managers to enable them to appropriately manage grievance matters.
- Ensure that recommendations made as part of grievance outcomes are fulfilled.
- Ensure that this policy remains relevant and legally compliant.
5.Confidentiality
5.1 All matters dealt with under the grievance procedure will be conducted in the strictest confidence. There is a need to protect both the aggrieved person and the individual against whom the grievance is raised from malicious allegations or rumours.
5.2 WMFS will deal with grievance matters sensitively and with due respect for the privacy of the individuals involved. You must treat any information communicated to you in connection with this policy as confidential.
5.3 Data collected as part of informal complaints and the grievance procedure is held securely and accessed by, and disclosed to, individuals only for the purposes of responding to the complaints or conducting the grievance procedure.
5.4 In some cases, the evidence given by individuals – or their identity – may have to remain confidential. Where confidentiality is necessary, we will provide you with an appropriate summary of the evidence.
5.5 All formal meetings under this policy will be recorded and transcribed. You or anyone accompanying you (including witnesses) must not make additional electronic recordings of any meetings or hearings conducted under this policy unless agreed as a reasonable adaption in advance.
5.6 Where it is identified that there has been an unwarranted breach of confidentiality from any party involved in the grievance process, then this may warrant an investigation and/or disciplinary action.
5.7 There will be times when confidentiality cannot be maintained, particularly where criminal, disciplinary or management issues come to light. In order to resolve these situations, it may be necessary to involve others. In these circumstances, Grievance Managers will discuss the disclosure of information with you prior to the involvement of others
6.The Grievance Stages
The Grievance policy has 3 stages:
- Informal
- Formal
- Appeal
7.Informal Grievances
7.1 We recognise that by working together managers, employees and trade union representatives can work towards resolving issues at an early stage – often removing the need for invoking formal procedures. Many problems can be raised and settled promptly and informally during the course of everyday working relationships. This may take the form of open and constructive discussions, mediation or facilitated meetings.
7.2 We are committed to attempting to resolve issues and we encourage you to bring concerns to your manager as they arise. If your manager is the subject of your grievance, and you feel unable to raise the complaint directly with them, you can approach another manager or appropriate person such as trade union representative to try and help mediate and resolve the grievance.
7.3 Informal discussions should take place at the earliest opportunity to avoid any further escalation. The informal process should not be unnecessarily delayed.
7.4 As a line manager, HR can help you navigate these conversations in a sensitive and supportive way.
7.5 Not all attempts to resolve issues will be successful. In this case, employees may need to consider raising a formal grievance under this procedure.
8.Mediation
8.1 Mediation can be a useful tool at any stage of this process – whether during the information stages to prevent escalation, or during/following formal stages to help repair relationships. A mediator can help resolve problems – especially those involving working relationships.
8.2 Mediation can be particularly helpful in concerns raised around conflict, working relationships, personality clashes, communication problems, and (in certain circumstances) bullying and harassment.
8.3 Mediation can provide a constructive way of resolving disputes and difficult situations. However, in order to work successfully it requires agreement from both parties involved before the mediation process can begin.
8.4 Mediation is a voluntary process where the mediator meets with two or more people in dispute to attempt to reach an agreement and does not apportion blame or take sides. It is for those in dispute to find the resolution – they will own and facilitate the process.
8.5 Mediation is most appropriate when both parties:
- are genuinely willing to communicate and agree a course of action.
- feel able to communicate openly and without fear of victimisation or reprisal.
- are prepared to focus on the future.
- are prepared to seek a constructive solution and do not wish for punishment as an outcome.
8.6 The Service will retain a list of trained mediators which may act as internal mediators in addition to their day job. Where appropriate, HR may also look to appoint an external mediator.
8.7 The process is flexible to meet individual needs but will usually involve the mediator meeting with you and other parties separately, before bringing you together to discuss. No notes from mediation sessions will be retained on file.
8.8 If mediation is not successful, you retain the right to continue with the formal stages of this policy.
8.9 To initiate the mediation process, managers can contact HR.
9.Raising a Formal Grievance
9.1 The formal grievance process should usually only be invoked after you have tried and been unable to resolve the matter informally – though we recognise that there will be cases where informal resolution is inappropriate.
9.2 We encourage employees to raise any workplace concerns or grievances as soon as possible so that they can be addressed promptly and effectively in order to maintain healthy and positive working relationships. Ordinarily, we would expect grievances to be raised within three months of the incident or issue occurring (or the last instance where there has been a sequence of events).
We recognise, however, that in some exceptional circumstances it may not be possible to raise a concern within this timeframe for a number of genuine reasons, including attempts to resolve issues outside of the grievance process.
9.3 You should submit your formal grievance to your line manager. If this is not appropriate this can be sent to the next level line manager, your Union Representative, or a HR Specialist.
9.4 In order to progress the grievance and allow full investigation, you will need to consider the following:
- What are the relevant details of your complaint that we need to know, for example, dates and times of any incidents, names of witnesses?
- Have informal attempts been made to resolve your concerns and if so, how have these helped or hindered?
- If informal attempts have not been made – why not?
- What outcome are you looking for in raising this grievance? What does a ‘good’ resolution look like to you?
9.5 Once your grievance has been submitted, you will receive acknowledgement within 7 days with details of your invite to a grievance hearing.
9.6 Grievances will normally be heard by your line manager or their line manager. However, if this is not appropriate HR will appoint an alternative manager.
9.7 At this stage, relevant and appropriate information will be shared with the person named in the grievance, this is usually your grievance submission form and any supporting documentation relating to allegations made against them.
9.8 Witnesses interviewed as part of this process will only have access to select information shared with them relevant to helping them answer the Grievance Managers questions.
10.Collective Grievances
10.1 A collective grievance is where a number of employees have the same concern or have been affected by the same issue. A collective grievance can be submitted by a Trade Union Representative or an employee on behalf of a group of employees within the Service.
10.2 Every employee who is a signatory to the collective grievance is required to be named and have given their written consent for their representative to act and speak on their behalf.
10.3 Only the Trade Union Representative or nominated employees (up to 3) will attend grievance meetings as part of a collective grievance, although all aggrieved parties will receive copies of correspondence, meeting transcripts, and outcome letters.
11.Formal Grievance Hearing
11.1 It is essential to ensure that all parties have the opportunity to state their case and respond to any accusations. We will therefore invite you to a formal grievance meeting – whether you have raised the grievance, or whether you are a named person within it.
11.2 You will be given a minimum of 7 days notice of the Grievance Hearing. If you request, and the Grievance Manager agrees, it may be possible to hold the meeting earlier than this.
11.3 When you are invited to a grievance meeting, we will confirm in writing to you:
- Who will be present.
- Your right to representation.
- The suggested date and time.
11.4 If you are the subject of a grievance, the invite will also contain enough information for you to fully understand the grievance against you. In the event that the Service believes there is a reason relevant to the investigation to not provide you with this, you will be provided with a summary of the complaint.
11.5 If you require any reasonable adjustments for you to be able to take part in the process, you will need to make the HR aware before the meeting.
11.6 The purpose of a hearing is for the Grievance Manager to understand the facts and circumstances of the allegations to enable them to investigate. It is also your chance to you to explain the nature of your complaint and what action you feel should be taken to resolve the matter.
11.7 Present at a Grievance meeting will be:
- You and your chosen representative.
- The Grievance Manager
- A HR representative
11.8 If you have raised a grievance, will be given the opportunity to:
- Set out your grievance.
- Respond to any questions posed to deepen the Grievance Managers understanding.
- Ask questions.
- Name witnesses you feel would be appropriate (please note that the Grievance Manager will decide whether they are interviewed as part of this).
11.9 If you have had a grievance raised against you, will be given the opportunity to:
- Respond in full in the allegations and any questions posed.
- Set out any counter arguments.
- Submit any further evidence.
- Ask questions.
- Name witnesses you feel would be appropriate
11.10 Please note that though you may provide names of witnesses you feel relevant, the Grievance Manager will decide if the information they may provide is necessary to their investigation.
11.11 If you are unable to attend the grievance meeting because of circumstances beyond your control, you should inform the manager conducting the meeting as soon as possible. You can do this directly, or through your Union Representative or Service Liaison Officer.
11.12 If you fail to attend without explanation, or if it appears that you have not made sufficient attempts to attend, the grievance meeting may take place in your absence, based on your written grievance statement and any other documentation available.
12.Investigating a Formal Grievance
12.1 In some circumstances, it may be possible for the Grievance Manager to reach a decision on the basis of the grievance hearing alone and any evidence that you present. It may, however, be necessary for the manager to conduct an investigation and interview other individuals before they are able to reach an outcome of the grievance.
12.2 Typically, a grievance investigation will involve the following:
- Examining the detail of the grievance provided in the grievance submission.
- Gathering and reviewing relevant documentation.
- Meeting with the person raising the grievance.
- Meeting with any named employees (if that is the nature of the grievance)
- Meeting with witnesses who may have information about the complaint.
12.3 The Grievance Manager has the discretion to determine the scope of any investigation, and the order in which they arrange the above may also vary on a case by case basis.
12.4 It is in the best interests of those involved in a formal grievance process that resolution is found as quickly as possible. All those involved must therefore give appropriate priority to the grievance to enable expedition of the process.
12.5 As a guide, we expect investigations to be completed within 2 weeks of the initial Grievance Hearing. Any extension required to this timeframe – for example due to annual leave – will be communicated and agreed with you.
12.6 There may be occasions where it is appropriate or necessary to engage an external Grievance Manager to conduct the investigation. If this is the case you will be notified before the process begins.
12.7 Where possible, the Grievance Manager will confirm their outcome to you face to face (either in person or on teams) and follow this up in writing to you as soon as is possible (including a copy of their investigation report). If arranging a face to face meeting may cause significant delays in delivering an outcome we will offer you the option of having this issued in writing first, with the option available to meet at a later date.
12.8 If you are a named person within a grievance, you will receive an outcome letter, detailing any recommendations relevant to you.
13.Potential Formal Grievance Outcomes
13.1 Grievance issues are often not necessarily clear cut and responsibility cannot always be decisively established. Grievance managers will make decisions based on the ‘balance of probabilities’, meaning they will consider, having weighed up the evidence, whether it is more likely than not that the complaint has been substantiated.
13.2 Potential outcomes of a grievance investigation are:
- Upheld – The Grievance Manager has found sufficient evidence to fully support the grievance raised.
- Partially upheld – The Grievance Manager has found evidence that supports some elements of the grievance but does not support other elements of it. This will be clearly documented within the investigation report.
- Not upheld – The Grievance Manager has not found evidence to support the grievance or there is insufficient evidence to be able to make a judgement.
13.3 Each grievance is unique and may require tailored responses. The investigation report will therefore often also include further recommendations. These could include further training, mediation, or coaching. It is the responsibility of your manager and HR to ensure that these recommendations are followed through.
13.4 The Grievance Manager may also make a recommendation that other formal processes are evoked as a result of their investigation, such as disciplinary or performance management.
14.Appeals Process
14.1 You will have 10 days from the date you receive the outcome in writing to appeal the outcome of a grievance. If an appeal is not made by you within these timescales, the Service will assume that you accept the decision made at any part of the process and you will be out of time to appeal (unless there are exceptional extenuating circumstances).
14.2 The reasons for your appeal should centre on:
a) A perceived unfairness of the judgement.
b) New evidence coming to light that you feel would have changed the outcome.
c) A serious process flaw where policy has not been followed and may have influenced the outcome.
14.3 The appeal will be a review of the grievance decision and not a new investigation. It will examine the grounds of the appeal, the procedures followed and the reasonableness of the outcome.
14.4 On receipt of the appeal, arrangements will be made to hear the grounds of appeal at a formal appeal meeting as soon as possible. The Appeal Manager will not have previously been included in the process and, will be of a more senior position than the person who delivered the outcome.
14.5 The Appeal Manager may adjourn the hearing if they need to carry out further investigations into any new evidence presented, or to further review the process. Any findings from this will be shared with you, and the appeal meeting reconvened within 7 days.
14.6 You have the right to be accompanied at an appeal hearing by a colleague or union representative.
14.7 There is no right of appeal for upheld grievance.
14.8 The outcome of the appeal hearing will be one of the following:
- Appeal upheld in full and further recommendations made.
- Appeal partially upheld and a review of the recommendations carried out.
- Appeal not upheld and the original outcome stands.
14.9 The appeal manager will confirm their decision face to face and follow this up in writing to you as soon as is possible. This then concludes the appeal process and there is no further right to appeal.
15.Your Right to be Accompanied
15.1 You have a statutory right to be accompanied to all formal meetings by either a work colleague or trade union representative. However, if either you or your chosen representative are not available, or in exceptional circumstances, we will work with you and your representative to find a suitable alternative date within seven days of the original hearing.
15.2 There is no obligation on a trade union official or a work colleague to accept a request to be your representative and they should not be pressurised to do so.
15.3 When opting to be supported by a work colleague, WMFS may choose to refuse your choice of companion if it is felt to be inappropriate and/or creates a conflict of interest.
15.4 The Service may, at its discretion, allow you to bring a companion who is not a colleague or union representative (for example, a member of your family) if this will help overcome a disability, language or other barrier.
15.5 The primary role of the representative is to confer with you, take relevant notes on your behalf and to offer moral support where needed. The representative is allowed to address the meeting in order to:
- Put forward your complaint on your behalf.
- Sum up your grievance.
- Ask questions.
- Request to confer privately with you.
- Respond to any view expressed at the hearing on your behalf.
15.6 Although the representative may respond on your behalf to any views expressed in a meeting, they may not address the meeting if you do not wish them to, or if it prevents you from explaining your case.
16.Unable to Attend a Formal Meeting
16.1 If you are unable to attend a formal meeting under this policy, this will be rearranged within 7 days.
16.2 If you are unable to attend due to a medical reason, the Grievance Manager will explore reasonable adjustments to the process with you, such as a change of venue or allowing you to participate via Microsoft Teams. Advice from Occupational Health may also be sought.
16.3 If you refuse to participate in the process, the Grievance Manager may continue with the process and make a judgement on the information they have. It is therefore important that you input into the process in as full and fair a way as possible.
17.Former Employees
17.1 If you leave the Service and have an outstanding grievance, we will find an appropriate way of concluding the grievance, depending on the nature of the grievance and the stage reached.
17.2 We would hope that grievances are raised and addressed before an employee leaves the Service, although it is recognised that there may be instances where this is not possible. Therefore, a leaver is able to raise a grievance within 1 month of the end of their employment.
17.3 If a grievance is outstanding, or raised after leaving, a modified process will be followed. This will usually consist of the leaver issuing a statement in writing, including the grievance and the basis for it. We will then investigate the concerns and issue a response in writing to the leaver. There will be no meetings as part of this modified process and there is no right of appeal.
18.Grievances whilst in other formal processes
18.1 If you raise a grievance whilst you are subject to another formal process – for example disciplinary – if the grievance is unrelated to those proceedings, the procedures will normally run independently in parallel.
18.2 If your grievance is in relation to a formal process you are currently part of – for example you have a procedural issue with a disciplinary process – the presiding manager will consider suspending the process for a short period whilst the grievance is heard.
19.Service Liaison Officer (SLO)
19.1 At all formal stages of this process a Service Liaison Officer will be appointed as your key welfare contact. This applies whether you have raised a formal grievance, or are a named person within one.
19.2 Their role is to support you through the process impartially and signpost you to available support.
19.3 They will not be involved in your case but will have a knowledge of the policy and can help you understand what to expect from a formal meeting and what next steps may be – particularly if you do not have union representation. They can also arrange occupational health referrals for you if you feel this is necessary.
19.4 If you would prefer, they may also act as an intermediatory between you, the Grievance Manager, or HR.
19.5 You can agree with your Service Liaison Officer how you would prefer to be contacted and they will let you know their availability.
20.Debrief Services
20.1 Debriefs are available for managers involved in decision making through Human Resources and Occupational Health. Employees and Union Representatives will be invited to feed into the HR debrief through the completion of a feedback form. If a structured debrief is required, Organisational Learning and Intelligence will be able to facilitate.
21.Support Available
We recognise that taking part in a grievance process can be difficult.
If you are struggling, below are some ways in which you can get support:
Employee Assistance Programme (EAP) – 0800 023 9324
Speak completely confidentially to a third party with anonymity assured. They offer telephone counselling, access to self help books and podcasts, and are available 24/7 365 days a year.
Fire Service Chaplains
Mental Health Advocates
Union Support:
Your union representative can help support you with the process, attend formal meetings with you, and help you feel prepared – whilst also offering personal support.