This document sets out the policy and procedures for compliments or complaints to be raised with West Midlands Fire Service (WMFS), as well as the process for employees to follow when a compliment or complaint has been received. It explains how individuals can raise matters with WMFS and how they will be dealt with once received. The Service is committed to an open and honest culture that enables people to tell us about their experiences and not to feel disadvantaged when doing so.
Policy Statement
WMFS exists to protect and serve the communities of the West Midlands, and we are proud of the services that we provide. We receive many compliments about our work, but we do not always get it right, and our communities have the right to raise concerns about the standard of service that we have provided.
Through this policy, which is in line with the LGSCO Complaint Handling Code, we aim to:
Follow a consistent procedure – we want to ensure that all matters raised through this avenue have a fair, consistent, and structured process for addressing them.
For this process to be positive – if the matter relates to a compliment about one of our team, we want them to know that they have done a great job. If the matter relates to a complaint, then we will use this for organisational learning and service improvement.
To be accessible – we want this process to be easy to follow, and all contact will be clear and free of jargon. We are committed to treating everyone fairly. If there are barriers in accessibility, then please let us know, and we will do our very best to support.
Scope
This policy applies to all compliments, complaints, and feedback received by WMFS from members of the public, stakeholders or any other individuals that interact with the Service.
This policy is not intended to cover internal complaints or grievances made by employees, as this will be addressed by the relevant internal employment policy. In addition, this policy is not intended for use by those who have left employment raising a historic employment matter.
However, an employee or ex-employee can make a complaint about the service we have provided to them as a member of the public.
Core code of ethics
The Fire Service Core Code of Ethics is of paramount importance, as it serves as a guiding compass for the actions and behaviour of every individual within our Service.
The code ensures that all WMFS employees uphold the highest standards of integrity, professionalism, and commitment to public safety, both on and off duty. It fosters a culture of trust, accountability, and respect within the service and towards the communities we serve.
The Fire Service Core Code of Ethics serves as a constant reminder of our commitment to the communities we serve.
Definitions
- Compliment: Letting us know about something that we did well.
- Complaint: An expression of dissatisfaction about our services and/or staff conduct.
- Complainant: The individual(s) making the complaint
- Feedback: Sharing an idea or suggestion about how we can improve, or sharing information with the service that may be helpful to the way that we carry out our services
- Service request: a request that the organisation provides or improves a service, fixes a problem or reconsiders a decision.
- CCC: Compliments, comments and complaints
Compliment procedure
WMFS and our employees gratefully accept compliments from members of our communities and/or those who interact with our service.
On receipt of a compliment via our website compliment form, an automated response will be sent. All compliments will then be personally acknowledged by the Reward and Recognition Advisor (or in their absence the Reward and Recognition Business Partner) and the compliment will be logged on our internal database.
The compliment will be communicated to the relevant manager so they are aware that the feedback has been received, and they will then share the compliment with the relevant individual, ensuring that they are appropriately acknowledged for the service they have provided.
Where individuals receive regular positive feedback, this will form part of the WMFS’s recognition strategy.
All compliments and good practices will be reviewed by the service’s Senior Leadership Team (SLT) on a regular basis.
Complaints procedure
Service requests:
Members of the public may wish us to improve something or reconsider a decision we have made, but this does not have to take the form of a complaint in order to be considered. The service should have a chance to manage this request without resorting immediately to the complaint procedure.
Such requests should be recorded and monitored by the relevant team to which they are made. This will be treated as a normal inquiry or service request, can is not subject to the process here. However, suppose an individual remains dissatisfied with how their request is handled or the service has failed to respond within agreed-upon timelines. In that case, they can raise the matter as a complaint.
Out-of-scope complaints:
There are some complaints that fall outside of the remit of this policy.
- Complaints (from current employees/volunteers) regarding employment matters: These concerns should be raised using the relevant internal employment policy.
- Complaints (from ex-employees) regarding employment matters: These concerns should, in the first instance, be addressed during the course of employment. Once this process is concluded, then such matters should be referred to the Advisory, Conciliation, and Arbitration Service (ACAS) or to the Employment Tribunal.
- Complaints regarding the conduct of a member of the West Midlands Fire & Rescue Authority (WMFRA): These concerns should be sent to the Monitoring Officer (Satinder.Sahota@wmfs.net) or Democratic Services (democratic.services@wmfs.net) for investigation in line with the Members Code of Conduct
- Complaints relating to criminal acts: Whilst WMFS will explore these matters in line with employment policies, linked to employment legislation, the matter should also be referred to the relevant police service for consideration. WMFS is unable to determine whether a criminal act has taken place.
- Complaints made from one member of a professional body about another: These complaints should be reported to the relevant regulating body for investigation.
- Complaints linked to a concern which took place more than 12 months ago: These matters will not be investigated unless the complainant can demonstrate that they have known about the action(s) for less than twelve months, or when the matter may bring the service into disrepute.
- Complaints regarding handling of personal data: There is a separate process operated by the Data Governance Team to process complaints of this nature. If there has been a personal data breach reported externally through the complaints process, then the Data Protection Officer must be notified immediately. This is because under the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) an organisation has 72 hours (about 3 days) to investigate and inform the Information Commissioner (ICO) should it be determined that a breach has occurred.
Stage 1 – Receiving complaints
Complaints can be submitted via email, letter or through our website’s contact form. We will also accept verbal and in-person complaints if necessary. A complaint may be received by any member of WMFS, and that individual should record the complaint on the Services internal CCC system based on the information that they have been provided.
Complainants should provide as much specific information as possible, including date, time, location (if applicable), people involved (if known) and any other relevant details about the complaint. Anonymous complaints will be accepted, but contact information could facilitate a more effective investigation and resolution process.
On receipt of a complaint, an automated response will be sent to the complainant if the complaint is made through the decided complaints form, advising that a response will be provided within 10 days. The complaint will be logged on our internal database.
Relevant and appropriate investigations (which may or may not involve requesting further information from the complainant) will take place into the complaints being raised, and the service aims to respond to all concerns within 10 days of the concern being raised. Where it is anticipated that the internal process may take longer than this, then the Senior HR Manager will write to inform the complainant, providing that contact details have been provided.
Once the matter has been concluded, then the complainant will be notified in writing, providing that contact details have been provided, explaining findings and, if applicable, any actions taken or proposed to resolve the complaint.
For those at WMFS who receive complaints, the LGO has provided further training resources.
Escalation of complaints
Stage 2 (internal escalation):
Where the complainant is dissatisfied with the outcome of their complaint then they are able to escalate the complaint. Escalations should be submitted in writing within 20 days of the initial complaint response being given. The escalation should identify the reasons for the dissatisfaction and the resolution which is being sought.
Investigations will then be undertaken by an independent member of the Senior Leadership Team. This individual will confirm their outcomes in writing to the complainant.
(External escalation):
Should the complainant remain dissatisfied with the actions that have taken place within WMFS, then they should consider raising their complaint to the Local Government Ombudsman. All correspondence with the Ombudsman will be via the Clerk to the Fire Authority.
At this stage, whilst WMFS will support further investigations undertaken by the Ombudsman, the service has no influence over the process or associated timescales.
Additional support
Where those wishing to make a complaint require additional support, this will be provided wherever possible. This provision will extend to providing any documents pertaining to the complaints Policy/Procedure. This might include involving ‘Language Line’, where a complainant has limited English, providing large-print leaflets to those with a visual impairment, or, where somebody has learning disabilities, meeting with the complainant and their advocate to record the details and explain the investigation process to them appropriately.
Reporting CCC Performance
In line with the Terms of Reference of the Authority Scrutiny Committee, a six-monthly report on complaint handling will be provided for consideration by members. This will include the number of Complaints, Comments and Compliments received, percentage of CCC responded to within agreed timescales, and CCC themes.
An annual complaints performance and service improvement report will also be produced and reported to the Scrutiny Committee. This report will be published on the section of the website relating to complaints, alongside the Scrutiny Committee’s response to the report.
Confidentiality
Those receiving complaints or otherwise associated with, or interviewed as part of an investigation, should keep their involvement and any details of the complaint, the investigation, those under investigation or the identity of the complainant confidential. Failure to do so may result in further investigation in line with the service’s disciplinary policy.
Unreasonable, and/or unreasonably persistent complainants
As a service, we understand that there may be contributing factors – such as a decline in mental health – as to why an individual may raise a large number of complaints or repeatedly pursue unreasonable outcomes of an investigation. It is therefore important to us to assure our communities that anyone raising complaints in this way will always be treated in line with our values as a Service.
However, if we consider that a complaint is unreasonable and/or vexatious, or where a complainant persistently raises the same (or similar concerns) then a relevant member of the Senior Leadership Team will review and decide whether the complaint will be looked into, or not. This approach may be considered necessary where:
We have reason to believe that the complaint is of vexatious nature. For the avoidance of doubt, vexatious behaviour may include:
- It is abusive, offensive, or directly or indirectly threatening in nature, including the use of offensive or demeaning language.
- The request is insisting on immediate responses to numerous, frequent and/or complex letters, telephone calls or emails.
- Sufficient opportunity to respond to existing requests has not been provided.
- It is repetitive, excessive, or duplicates previous correspondence without new information. This includes instances where the same request is directed through multiple routes.
- It imposes an unreasonable burden on our resources, preventing us from effectively fulfilling our duties.
- It demonstrates a disregard for the facts or evidence presented in previous responses.
- It is made with the primary intention of causing disruption or annoyance rather than seeking resolution.
Where the decision is made that the complaint is vexatious, persistent, and/or unreasonable, then the complaint shall not receive a response to the concern, but will be notified of the decision and the rationale for this decision. There is no right to appeal this decision. However, in instances such as this, the complainant shall be notified of their options for progressing their concerns.
Complaints of this nature will still be logged and reported on, in line with all other complaints.