Firefighter pensions – Why do I have to submit evidence for a Contingent Decision?
We understand it may seem like eligibility for a contingent decision should be clear-cut and that the pensions team could determine who is or isn’t eligible in advance. Unfortunately, this is not the case. For both opt-outs and additional service, a contingent decision is based on decisions you made and the reasons you made them. You have to be able to show that a decision you made (such as to opt-out from the scheme) or did not make (such as to buy additional years in the scheme) would have been different if it were not for the changes between 2015-2022 which the courts later found to have been discriminatory. Only you can know your intent, or what you would or would not have done. For example, if you opted out of the pension scheme during this period but for reasons other than the changes to the scheme, you would not be eligible for a contingent decision.